Can This Guy Get People to Live in America’s Emptiest Downtown?

0
3
Can This Guy Get People to Live in America’s Emptiest Downtown?


DENVER—Developer Asher Luzzatto stared out at the snow-capped Rocky Mountains one recent April afternoon, admiring the postcard view from the 29th floor of his recently acquired office tower.

Asher Luzzatto paid just $5.25 million for this two-building complex in downtown Denver.

Then he turned his gaze lower, to the streets surrounding the downtown Denver building, where he glimpsed a less-inspiring sight: vacant store fronts, empty office buildings with darkened floors, and deserted streets.

The property, one of two office towers known as the Energy Center, is a testament to downtown Denver’s rapid decline. Luzzatto picked up the 785,000 square foot complex late last year for a little more than $5 million—97% below what a previous owner paid for it in 2013.

America’s downtowns are suffering a crisis. Office work has migrated into the suburbs, leaving abandoned buildings and blighted conditions behind. Central business districts from St. Louis to Dallas and Portland, Ore., are fighting to escape a death spiral.

Luzzatto has a plan to fix these downtown catastrophes. He is starting in Denver, where nearly 40% of the office space in the central business district is vacant, the highest among the country’s top 50 cities, according to real-estate services firm CBRE Group.

Cities built forests of skyscrapers when white-collar employment was inseparable from downtowns, and workers poured in daily from bedroom communities. But when remote work became more popular and these downtowns continued to deteriorate, waves of companies moved out jobs and business districts collapsed.

Luzzatto’s approach is to turn that old formula inside out, transforming desolate urban cores into welcoming places to live. He plans to convert half of the Energy Center plus two other downtown Denver office buildings into about 1,100 apartments. He’s also planning a bookstore, art gallery, children’s museum and daycare center.

He acquired all four buildings for pennies on the dollar. In a matter of months, the Los Angeles native has taken control of more than 7% of Denver’s traditional downtown office space. Those rock-bottom purchase prices make it economically feasible to convert his mostly empty office towers into residential buildings, he says. He said that his competitors, other bidders for the downtown properties, “had a lot of trouble seeing past what is here today.”

Luzzatto is planning to turn the atrium into a community space for new residents, complete with a bakery, a wine-and-beer bar, a bookstore and a bodega, as seen in this rendering.

Luzzatto’s utopian vision for reimagining downtown Denver—and for providing a template to revitalize America’s other broken downtowns—faces a number of serious challenges.

He has to contend with high construction costs and lenders who are often skeptical of such complex conversion projects. He has to figure out how to navigate rigid building codes and revise office layouts to work for housing.

Perhaps hardest of all, part of his scheme is to convince a number of Denver employees who work outside the city center to move into his transitional downtown neighborhood and endure a reverse commute.

But he received a vote of confidence in March, when the Downtown Denver Development Authority approved a $63 million loan toward his plans. It was the quasi-government entity’s largest loan ever.

And Luzzatto insists there is a market downtown for affordable housing that offers priceless views. “Imagine if this were your apartment,” he said, motioning to the majestic peaks to the west.

Denver’s recently reopened 16th Street Mall, seen here in late April, is drawing visitors again, but traffic remains below city officials’ ambitions for the corridor. 

The birth of Downtown America

Modern U.S. cities developed in the early 20th century around a single organizing principle: White-collar work was concentrated in dense central business districts. Even as residents moved to the suburbs and cities grappled with poverty and crime, that model largely endured—until recently, when technology and shifting living and working patterns threatened many of these districts with obsolescence.

Early in the office downturn, starting in 2020, planners and architects cautioned that office-to-residential conversions would barely make a dent in the housing shortage. They were simply too expensive to undertake. But the rapid plunge in office values, along with the growing willingness of cities to provide subsidies, is changing that equation.

The area around the New York Stock Exchange, shown in the early 20th century, has seen an influx of full-time residents in recent decades.

Now, developers are moving ahead with plans in Chicago, Washington, D.C., Cleveland and other cities to convert these emptying office towers into new residences.

In New York, long the nation’s leader in conversions, activity used to be concentrated in lower Manhattan. Now it is spreading to Midtown. Developers in Washington are deploying similarly aggressive design hacks, cutting holes through deep floor plates and reworking interiors to bring light into apartments.

The number of office-to-apartment conversions in the U.S. pipeline at the start of 2026 grew to 90,300 units, a 28% increase from a year earlier, according to apartment search website RentCafe.

While a plan as ambitious as Luzzatto’s is rare in the U.S., a similar effort has shown promise in Canada. Calgary, Alberta, suffered from a similar glut of empty office space after a downturn in the energy industry. In 2021, the city launched a subsidized program to promote residential conversions, which helped spur close to two dozen such projects. Eight are complete and enjoying strong demand at rents that make them profitable, developers say.

“The program has worked,” said Maxim Olshevsky, chief executive of Astra Group, one of the most active Calgary converters.

In Denver, plans to create a modern downtown started in the mid-20th century, when the city razed taverns, flophouses and dilapidated tenements in an urban-renewal push. The effort paid off during the oil boom of the 1970s and 1980s.

Denver razed taverns and tenements to make way for skyscrapers such as this one, shown under construction in 1957.

But the redevelopment wiped out much of Denver’s historic fabric, leaving uneven stretches that never developed the dense, mixed-use character needed today for a vibrant downtown. The later building boom compounded the problem, prioritizing speed and scale over street-level design, with towers rising with little attention to pedestrians, retail or everyday life.

“The buildings were just commodities,” said Jon Buerge, chief executive and partner at Denver developer Urban Villages. “There was never really a dedication to the urban fabric.”

Even so, between 2010 and 2019 Denver was booming. It was drawing tens of thousands of new residents each year, with its outdoor vibe and early legalization of cannabis. The city also reaped the benefits of public investments in the Union Station neighborhood, renovating historic buildings and creating an entertainment district and new housing.

“There was an hour wait for the Chipotle at noon,” said Sam Kelly, a 56-year-old state employee, outside the office building he works out of two days a week. “You would hear a lot of horns. There was a lot of traffic.”

But little was done to address the warning signs that vacancy was creeping up downtown as work habits changed. Then the pandemic hit and Denver offices emptied out. And when companies did bring employees back, demand shifted further away from the sterile downtown core, flowing instead to suburban office hubs, or to Denver’s newer districts like the area around Union Station and the River North Arts District.

Today Denver has a remote-work rate well above the national average. That’s hardly surprising. In a region where skiing, hiking and rock climbing are woven into daily life, many workers are reluctant to trade flexible schedules for long downtown commutes.

Kelly, the state employee, says he often bikes on days he works remotely. “That’s part of working from home,” he said. “Plus you avoid two hours of traffic a day.”

Lawrence Welk’s money man

Luzzatto, 38-years old, is slight of build with an urban hipster’s wispy beard. He grew up in Santa Monica, Calif., but recently moved to Taos, N.M., where he spends time riding horses and hiking with his family along the Rio Grande. He meditates regularly.

Real estate is in his blood. His father started a development firm after running the real-estate arm of bandleader Lawrence Welk’s family office. Dinner-table conversations revolved around buildings, neighborhoods and property deals.

The elder Luzzatto was an early believer in what would come to be called creative office space, a precursor to today’s office-to-residential conversion movement. He transformed old industrial buildings, like the warehouse tied to the Welk family’s record-label business, into loft-like offices.

Later, father and son worked on projects from Maui to Chicago—including a former dairy facility in Los Angeles that was converted into the headquarters of Sweetgreen—giving Luzzatto an education in reimagining what spaces could become.

When he became a developer, Luzzatto saw repurposing L.A.’s oversupply of office space into housing as key to solving the city’s housing shortage. He hatched a radical idea: Abolish all zoning and allow strong housing demand to naturally drive empty offices and other idle buildings into apartments. “Let the market figure it out because people are creative and solution-oriented,” he said.

Luzzatto traces his focus on affordable housing to an epiphany he had early in the pandemic, when he was sitting under an olive tree outside his Los Angeles home during his morning meditation. He was overwhelmed by gratitude—his first child, time at home, a sense of calm—but that feeling quickly gave way to something else: a recognition that for many people, the same moment was defined by stress, cramped apartments, lost jobs and uncertainty.

Asher Luzzatto poses for a portrait in the atrium of his new Denver project.

“I started crying,” he recalls. “I felt this overwhelming sense of joy—and then this deep sadness that so many people couldn’t experience that same thing.”

In 2021, Luzzatto launched a long-shot bid for mayor of Los Angeles, hoping at least to force his anti-zoning housing plan to the center of the campaign. He withdrew a few months later, after mall developer Rick Caruso entered the race with far greater financial resources.

“I feel like we had the right message,” Luzzatto said.

He returned to development intent on putting his housing vision into practice. He chose Denver, favoring a city that has repeatedly reinvented itself, and one filled with office towers that had collapsed in value.

When Luzzatto arrived in 2024, he expected to encounter buildings in disrepair. Instead, he found many had recently been upgraded, with modern interiors, new fitness centers and sleek co-working facilities installed by owners betting that office demand would rebound.

“Covid was followed by the wrong thesis that there’s going to be a massive return to work,” Luzzatto said. “Everyone spent a bunch of money in 2021 and 2022.”

That growth was layered onto old thinking—daily commuters and modern office districts—that left the core overly dependent on daytime workers and thin on housing and neighborhood life. When remote work took hold, that model unraveled quickly, emptying buildings and exposing just how fragile the downtown Denver economy had become.

“We had our real heyday and now we’re paying for it,” said Bill Mosher, a veteran real-estate executive tapped by Denver’s mayor to help revive the city’s struggling downtown core.

Luzzatto bought his first two Denver buildings a year ago. He plans to use the buildings’ long layouts and large window bays to create 750 units with oversize views of those majestic mountains. Seventy-five of the units will be affordable. Rents of the market rate units will run from about $1,700 for a studio to $4,500 for a three-bedroom.

“People are currently renting these three, four, five story, mid-rise, cheap-construction buildings on the side of the highway,” he said. “They’re going to have the ability to pay the same rent and be in the heart of downtown.”

Denver business hubs outside its downtown such as Cherry Creek are bustling, including the Cherry Lane redevelopment project.
Diners enjoy the spring weather in Cherry Creek in late April.

Between the first two buildings Luzzatto purchased sits a soaring, glass-topped interior courtyard from the mid-1970s, flooded with natural light and framed by balconies and walkways. He’s planning to install a bakery and coffee counter along one wall, a bookstore across from it, a wine-and-beer bar spilling into tables that connect to the courtyard and a bodega-style market.

Luzzatto’s family, and a longstanding group of investors his firm cultivated over the years, are providing his equity. Luzzatto has discussed the strategy at length with his father, who is still chairman, but less active on a day-to-day basis.

He paid $5.25 million for the Energy Center’s two towers, a cheaper price than what some of the nicer homes sell for in Denver’s Cherry Creek district.

The other two Denver office towers that Luzzatto purchased were valued at about $100 million in 2015 when purchased by investment giant Blackstone. Luzzatto paid $3.2 million—much less than what Blackstone spent on upgrades to the building and landscaping in the years following the pandemic.

“I was pleasantly surprised,” Luzzatto said of the new lobby. “They did a beautiful job.”

Still, getting people to live downtown won’t be easy. While Denver Mayor Mike Johnston, who took office in July 2023, has made progress in reducing crime and homelessness, many who left say they haven’t yet seen enough improvement to return.

“I have eyes and I can observe,” said Kyle Tormoehlen, 45, who works at a co-working space at the Denver Tech Center, a suburban office hub that competes with downtown. “It’s just not an attractive place to be anymore.”

Evan O’Connor, a 30-year-old who works for a finance company and rents in Denver’s Highlands neighborhood, would seem the perfect candidate to live in a converted office building.

But he says it’s not for him because he already spends much of his time “dealing with the stressful finance kind of vibe” in an office building. “I worry about separating my work life from my home life,” he said.

A high view from the 633 17th St. building.

Luzzatto faces plenty of other challenges, including Denver’s stringent energy standards and other building codes. He’s looking at a $30 million price tag on simply dealing with asbestos and replacing single-pane windows on just two of the buildings.

He says city officials have generally tried to work with him to cut through red tape, but he still has to meet requirements governing such things as lighting levels and how much new insulation has to be installed.

And he realizes that downtown Denver has been empty for so long that other types of residents have colonized parts of it, including the landscaping outside one of his buildings.

“Last night we were here—there were bunnies running around,” he said. “Think about that. In the middle of downtown!”

Write to Peter Grant at peter.grant@wsj.com


LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here